One thing I need to say up front: We are NOT all the same.
I’m sure that many of you think I just stated the obvious, but I had to say it because while many people accept that to be true, it seems to go right out the window when people begin planning communication campaigns.
The diversity of races is acknowledged, but somehow the idea of diversity within races does not make it into the conversation.
Most people who know me well are aware of the fact that my family is from the Caribbean. West Indian people and really anyone else who looks black in this country seem to get placed in the African-American category, but any 1st generation American with West Indian roots knows exactly how “African-American” our family members truly feel….
This is a bit of a rant, but it’s a rant with a purpose.
Yesterday I picked up the Sept/Oct issue of the Network Journal and decided to dig into their news brief section. I was pleasantly surprised by the fact that they dedicated a section just to data on Caribbean-Americans.
It’s so rare to see data on any segment of the broad group referred to as African-American that I can somewhat understand how groups of people from the Caribbean get lost in the planning process. Though I have a bit more cultural perspective here, I’m still a communications guy and I’ll admit the fact that it’s hard to craft and tailor messages for an audience on which there is not much data.
Here are a few interesting points from the Networking Journal:
As a professor I had in college often proclaimed, I say all this to say that in trying to reach the “African-American” audience or any defined racial group, it is worth taking the time to drill down a bit further and learn about existing cultural sub groups.
When we fail to do so, we miss a great opportunity to create campaigns that resonate with all areas of our target audiences, tap into their sizeable buying power, change perceptions and inspire people to take action.
Thanks for putting this out there. This issue has been driving me crazy for years. As a West Indian I’ve checked “other” far too many times on application forms when African-American is the only option listed for black.
Curious, would you be open to checking black? Or do you think there needs to be some sort of Caribbean-American designation?
I’m fine with checking black. Some applications don’t even have “black” as an option. Anything with “American” behind it doesn’t fit folks who aren’t American. I’m British, so “black” is all I need.
I can completely get your perspective. So many people who would identify as black but were neither born nor raised in America immediately become “African-American” in the eyes of others.
It was something that I noticed and just decided to put out there. Glad it resonated with you.
[...] American Reaching the “African-American” audience FYI–We aren’t monolithic. The conversation America won’t have on race The absence [...]
[...] often get into categorizing by race but stop at the surface, without digging deeper to look at subgroups. So it was extremely exciting to see people from an [...]